Losing $528/second based on $16.7B/year in lost revenue
California Wealth Exodus
The tax revenue already lost from the mere proposal of the Billionaire Tax Act Asset Seizure Act, announced October 22, 2025. Voters defeated it on November 3, 2026.
November 3, 2026 · Unofficial returns
The billionaire tax lost.
Proposition 40, the one-time 5% wealth tax, was defeated. Proposition 42 passed, and it bans new state wealth taxes going forward.
Proposition 40
Defeated
The one-time 5% tax on the net worth of California billionaires. Voters killed it.
No55.6%4,280,110
Yes44.4%3,419,652
Proposition 42
Passed
Bans new state personal-property and wealth taxes, and certain retroactive state taxes.
Yes54.3%4,150,258
No45.7%3,489,519
Unofficial returns as of the morning of November 4, 2026, pending certification by the California Secretary of State. Proposition 41, the spending-limit and audit countermeasure, also failed, 47.6% Yes to 52.4% No. Sources: The Ballot Book and San Jose Inside.
Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West qualified the Billionaire Tax Act for November 3, 2026. Dave Regan, the union's president, and Suzanne Jimenez were the lead proponents. They wanted a one-time 5% seizure of billionaire net worth. Voters told them no.
Prop 42 largely delivered the ban
This site called for a constitutional prohibition on asset-seizure taxes. Proposition 42 largely delivered it. The measure passed, and it bans new state personal-property and wealth taxes and certain retroactive state taxes.
The Looter Dream Team
A record of the proponents and the academics who drafted the Billionaire Tax Act.
On November 3, 2026, California voters defeated Proposition 40, the Billionaire Tax Act. Unofficial returns the morning of November 4: No 55.6% (4,280,110 votes) to Yes 44.4% (3,419,652). The one-time 5% asset seizure is dead. These numbers are not certified yet.
Proposition 42 passed, Yes 54.3% (4,150,258) to No 45.7% (3,489,519). It bans new state personal-property and wealth taxes, and certain retroactive state taxes. That is the constitutional wall this site said California had to build. Prop 42 largely delivered it.
Proposition 41, the spending-limit and audit countermeasure, failed, 47.6% Yes to 52.4% No. Voters did not need a second procedural trap. They rejected the seizure itself, and they passed the ban.
Unofficial California Secretary of State returns as of the morning of November 4, 2026, pending certification. The Ballot Book. San Jose Inside.
Even tax-loving organizations like Planned Parenthood and the California Teachers Association opposed it, because they knew it was BAD for California.
Why Californians opposed it
Killing the Golden Goose
Startups are the golden goose of California. They turn into the mega businesses that fund our state. The Billionaire Tax Act went right for the goose's throat. Voters defeated it. The founders who already left did not come back.
This Bill Would Have Made Startups Illegal
Incalculable is the number of businesses that will never be founded in California, or individuals and businesses that left because of this. This bill would have made startups illegal. It would have bankrupted any founder who had paper wealth in an early stage company but not actual liquid wealth.
The Damage is Already Done
The damage is already done. Billionaires have left and taken their tax revenue with them. This will have a chilling effect on California for decades to come. Prop 42 largely delivered the constitutional ban on asset-seizure taxes this site called for: it prohibits new state personal-property and wealth taxes and certain retroactive state taxes. A failed tax does not bring back the people who already left, or the revenue they took with them.
The End of Private Property
This initiative would have given CA legislators the right to take anyone's post-tax assets anytime in the future based on a majority vote. This was not about billionaires. It was a new "tax system" that would have destroyed private property rights in America. Voters said no, and Prop 42 wrote a ban on new state wealth taxes into the constitution.
Spend Smarter First
California already has the second highest taxes per capita in the country. Our budget has increased 62% since 2019. Let's use the budget we do have much more efficiently before we light more taxpayer dollars on fire. $24B in unaccounted-for homeless spending, $30B in unemployment fraud, $128B towards a high-speed rail to nowhere that will never get completed.
Better Alternatives Exist
This Asset Seizure Act was EXTREME. There were plenty of other options to raise tax revenue. Increase income tax, increase capital gains tax, tax loans against unrealized capital gains, eliminate the tax-free rollover of certain appreciated assets, or eliminate the step-up in basis on inheritance.
About the 2026 Billionaire Tax Act: Proposition 40 would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of California residents exceeding $1 billion, based on residency as of January 1, 2026. Real estate, pensions, and retirement accounts were excluded. Payment could have been made as a lump sum or spread over 5 years with a 7.5% annual deferral charge. Voters defeated it on November 3, 2026. Unofficial returns, pending certification: No 55.6% (4,280,110), Yes 44.4% (3,419,652). Proposition 42, which bans new state personal-property and wealth taxes and certain retroactive state taxes, passed.
Lost Tax Revenue: Calculated at 1.5% of net worth annually, representing estimated ongoing state tax revenue (income, capital gains, etc.) California loses each year when billionaires relocate.
Why Californians opposed it
Killing the Golden Goose
Startups are the golden goose of California. They turn into the mega businesses that fund our state. The Billionaire Tax Act went right for the goose's throat. Voters defeated it. The founders who already left did not come back.
This Bill Would Have Made Startups Illegal
Incalculable is the number of businesses that will never be founded in California, or individuals and businesses that left because of this. This bill would have made startups illegal. It would have bankrupted any founder who had paper wealth in an early stage company but not actual liquid wealth.
The Damage is Already Done
The damage is already done. Billionaires have left and taken their tax revenue with them. This will have a chilling effect on California for decades to come. Prop 42 largely delivered the constitutional ban on asset-seizure taxes this site called for: it prohibits new state personal-property and wealth taxes and certain retroactive state taxes. A failed tax does not bring back the people who already left, or the revenue they took with them.
The End of Private Property
This initiative would have given CA legislators the right to take anyone's post-tax assets anytime in the future based on a majority vote. This was not about billionaires. It was a new "tax system" that would have destroyed private property rights in America. Voters said no, and Prop 42 wrote a ban on new state wealth taxes into the constitution.
Spend Smarter First
California already has the second highest taxes per capita in the country. Our budget has increased 62% since 2019. Let's use the budget we do have much more efficiently before we light more taxpayer dollars on fire. $24B in unaccounted-for homeless spending, $30B in unemployment fraud, $128B towards a high-speed rail to nowhere that will never get completed.
Better Alternatives Exist
This Asset Seizure Act was EXTREME. There were plenty of other options to raise tax revenue. Increase income tax, increase capital gains tax, tax loans against unrealized capital gains, eliminate the tax-free rollover of certain appreciated assets, or eliminate the step-up in basis on inheritance.